---
title: "Banquet of Chestnuts"
year: 1501
canonical: "https://recap.at/1501/banquet-of-chestnuts"
slug: "banquet-of-chestnuts"
recapType: "global_event"
datePrecision: "day"
startDate: "1501-10-30"
---

# Banquet of Chestnuts

> On 31 October 1501, Cesare Borgia reportedly hosted a notorious supper in the Papal Palace in Rome.

The Banquet of Chestnuts was a supper said to have been hosted by Cesare Borgia, son of Pope Alexander VI, at the Papal Palace in Rome on 31 October 1501. The detailed account comes from one papal official's diary, and both contemporary and modern authors have questioned whether it is accurate, exaggerated or a later insertion.

## Summary

The Banquet of Chestnuts, also called the Ballet of Chestnuts, the Festival of Chestnuts or the Joust of Whores, was a supper purportedly held at the Papal Palace in Rome on 31 October 1501. Its host was former Cardinal Cesare Borgia, son of Pope Alexander VI, and the setting, according to the surviving account, was Cesare's own apartments in the Palazzo Apostolico.

That account sits in the Liber Notarum of Johann Burchard, a Protonotary Apostolic and Master of Ceremonies whose diary is a primary source on the life of Alexander VI. Burchard writes that fifty courtesans attended, danced with the guests first clothed and then naked, and crawled among candelabra placed on the floor to pick up scattered chestnuts while the Pope, Cesare and his sister Lucrezia watched. Prizes such as silk tunics, shoes and caps were then offered in a contest of a more carnal kind. The diary was kept in the Vatican Secret Archive and only reached researchers in the mid-19th century when Pope Leo XIII opened the archive, and Leo was openly reluctant to give general access to a document that might damage Alexander VI's reputation.

Whether the banquet happened as described is the real story. Two independent contemporary sources confirm that a social event took place on the date Burchard gives, but they offer far fewer details. The Belgian Vatican researcher Peter de Roo, in his five-volume history of Alexander VI, suggested the passage might be a later interpolation, on the grounds that the Pope could not have behaved so badly; other historians in turn criticised De Roo's biography as a vast apologetic work that uncritically rejected all criticism of Alexander VI. Alexander Lee notes that the episode is attested only in Burchard and was dismissed as implausible by many contemporaries, while the priest and historian Henry A. Brann argued that "courtesans" should read "courtiers" and that the nudity was just the removal of outer robes. On the other side, Giles Milton calls the Liber Notarum a deeply serious work and Burchard a generally reliable, unexaggerated witness, adding that the events fit a pope known for fathering more illegitimate children than any other.

The banquet has had a long afterlife in culture, often with less restraint than its sources. Heinrich Lossow's 1880 painting The Sin is believed to be inspired by it. William Manchester's 1992 book A World Lit Only by Fire embellished the original account and was dismissed or ignored by professional historians for its factual errors, with one reviewer in Speculum citing some of the most gratuitous errors he had read in a long time. The Showtime series The Borgias staged it in season 3, episode 4, recast as a blackmail trap for disloyal cardinals with no Borgias present at all.

## Key facts

- **Date**: 31 October 1501
- **Location**: Papal Palace (Palazzo Apostolico), Rome
- **Host**: Cesare Borgia, son of Pope Alexander VI
- **Main source**: Liber Notarum of Johann Burchard
- **Corroboration**: Two contemporary sources confirm a social event on that date, with fewer details
- **Status**: Historicity disputed

## Timeline

- **1501-10-31** - The banquet
  According to Burchard, Cesare Borgia hosts a supper with fifty courtesans in his chambers in the Vatican.
- **1880** - Lossow's The Sin
  Heinrich Lossow paints The Sin, a work believed to be inspired by the Banquet of Chestnuts.
- **1992** - A World Lit Only by Fire
  William Manchester publishes a book that embellishes Burchard's account and is dismissed by professional historians.

## Consequences

- **1880 - Inspiration for The Sin**: Heinrich Lossow's painting The Sin, showing a nun and a monk, is believed to draw on the banquet.
- **1992 - Popular retelling criticised**: William Manchester's embellished version in A World Lit Only by Fire was dismissed or ignored by historians for its factual errors.

## Impact

A single diary entry, questioned from the start and later embellished, left a lasting mark on how the Borgia court is remembered, inspiring an 1880 painting, a much-criticised 1992 book and an episode of the Showtime series The Borgias.

## Sources

- [Banquet of Chestnuts](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banquet_of_Chestnuts) - Wikipedia

---
Canonical: https://recap.at/1501/banquet-of-chestnuts